Quay Park & Ngati Whatua – First decision


Bob Dey has reported on the first of the Quay Park arbitrations to be released in his property report.

Parnell Terraces at 18-24 The Strand is one of 5 apartment developments on the former railway land at Quay Park on which former High Court judge Robert Fisher has made decisions as arbitrator. He’s also decided valuations on the GE Finance & BNZ buildings, which haven’t been released.

The Ngati Whatua valuers, Sean Molloy of Extensor Advisory & Reid Quinlan, have been more or less vindicated.  The landlord’s valuers put values of $13.4 million & $13.402 million on the Parnell Terraces land.

Valuers for the body corporates, Iain Gribble & Nigel Dean, were going for $7.5 million from Mr Gribble and $6.116 million from Mr Dean.  End result:

The Parnell Terraces ground rent was fixed under arbitration at $760,670/year – 6% of the assessed land value of $12,344,500, for 7054m² of land at $1750/m².

Pretty close to the landlord’s figure.

Good example, btw, of how malleable and subjective valuations can be, driven by who is giving the instruction.  These are all experienced valuers, sitting absolute poles apart on the same ground.  Had they been instructed by the opposite parties, would their positions have reversed?  They might argue not.  I’ve seen different often enough, although not from those valuers specifically.

Advertisements

About Ivan McIntosh

I am a partner of Carter Atmore Law...residing in City Road just off the busy thoroughfare of Symonds Street, Auckland, New Zealand....where we are specialist business & property development lawyers, working for both local and international clients. Proud husband to Joanna, and dad to two sons. Passionate rugby supporter. Email: imcintosh@calaw.co.nz Ph: 64 9 921 5026
This entry was posted in Commercial Property, Leases & Leasehold, Litigation, Property Law, Residential property and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Quay Park & Ngati Whatua – First decision

  1. Phillip says:

    Such close figures between the landlord’s and the body corporate valuers!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s